TAX-EXEMPTION IS IN THE EYE OF THE BEHOLDER

Tax Exemption is in the Eye of the Beholder
by Pam Ashlund

What is the life cycle of a nonprofit organization? What can we expect as we move from visionaries, to implementers, to administrators? Organizational Development professionals have come up with some very valuable takes on the life cycle of nonprofits; and our funding sources have started to rely on that research in their funding selection process.

Seems there are some pretty predictable things that happen as we evolve and therefore we can learn from those we follow. Going through an assessment process can be quite the value-added exercise.

But today I happened upon a different kind of nonprofit life cycle (on the IRS website).

The IRS has a peculiar take on the nonprofit "life cycle"; or maybe not. It is true that life has a beginning, a middle and an end. And that is how the IRS frames it. But their view doesn't just have an ending, it assumes it. Here's how it goes: a nonprofit starts up, then it ages and deals with keeping records over time and keeping up with the current laws (especially those of the IRS); then it goes through what the IRS names "Significant Events". And what is among these significant events? The nonprofit cracks up, does something that blows it, violates a significant law. The IRS calls this "termination of exempt organization". "Boom" that's it.

Now please (especially eager IRS agents) do not take this as an attack on this venerable organization. Just a tiny observation. Perhaps, when looking through the lens of an agency who's job is to collect taxes, this all makes sense.

But let's look at it through another set of eyes. How about these stages of development (often used by foundations to categorize nonprofits):

  • Infancy (start-up or start-over)
  • Juvenile (growth period)
  • Adolescence (growth and decline spurts
  • Maturity (established)

Note that the story isn't: start, comply, don't comply, close.



Hmmmm


Other resources on nonprofit stages:


Judy Simon's book:
The Five Life Stages of Nonprofit Organizations: Where You Are, Where You're Going, and What to Expect When You Get There

Technorati Tags:, , , , , , ,
Generated By Technorati Tag Generator

Comments

Nonprofit Pundit said…
I don't need to go to the IRS web site to point out that for the IRS there would never be any other life arc. A not for profit organization is by definition an entity that exists by virtue of the grace of the IRS. No matter what else the organization may do, the tax-exempt status we define ourselves by is ONLY a reflection of IRS Code designation, for which we not only must apply but must continue to qualify for. The fact that the tax code section (503c) has some 25 subsections to describe tax-exempt organizations, only one of which may pass along its exemption to its donors is quite telling. The c(3) designation is tied specifically to charitible activities, and many things we have assumed would be designated as c(3) in a prior era would be unlikely to get through the application procvess today.

But to return to the original point, until somewhat recently the IRS really only had death penalty options (that is to say complete status revocation) for dealing with inappropriate not-for-profit organizations. There are actually intermediate sanctions now available to the IRS for what are manifestly egregious acts, but often the organizational cost might as well be revocation as the fines are very stiff. Nonetheless, just as we are NOT precluded from operating with the same mission and activities with other than a (c)3 designation, we would be foolish to think that the organizational development perspective is TECHNICALLY related in any way whatsoever to that tax-exempt status. We might well be far better at doing our job if we kept in mind on a daily basis that before we make decisions we ask whether or not they would pass muster with the present IRS narrow vision. If we find that we are frequently uncertain, then we must ask if we ought to use those non-IRS self-evaluation standards to either honestly give-up our (c)3 pretentions, or seriously rethink what we are doing.
11/30/2006 12:17 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

THE LIES PEOPLE TELL US (AND THE ONES WE TELL OURSELVES)

"I don’t understand these fundraisers, …they waste all this money…why don't they just give the money to …the sick people?" "…you know what? They don’t! They throw a party so rich people like me can spend $10,000 on a table and then they give it to the sick people!" ...that’s how it’s done ! Joan Cusack to Jennifer Aniston in "Friends with Money" Alright, let's get this over with folks: Fundraisers are a Lie! Yes that's right you heard me. A few months back, I attended a luncheon to raise funds for a school for the deaf. Yes, it was luncheon and a fashion show and a fundraiser all in one. First there was the obligatory silent auction, then (during lunch) the not-so-silent auction, and then after lunch when the plates were taken away, we were asked if we would like to purchase the Orchid Centerpieces! Hadn't they got enough from us? Let me think-No! Easy as it is to lampoon a fundraiser, that is not where I am going today. One of the ladies w
Read more

GRAFITTI OR SOCIAL CHANGE?

Image
art institutions are a severely limited arena of reception for ideas about public issues --Robbie Conal If I can't take my coffee break, Gone is the sense of enterprise ...something within me dies. -- How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying I was born with a "Question Authority" bumper sticker metaphorically stuck on the back of my car. I grew up with that expression (and what it represents) as my moral imperative. But I've been worried lately. I've been worried because it doesn't seem to be turning out the way I thought it would. Seems a QA attitude is not necessarily conducive to civil society. It all depends on who's the authority I suppose. I seem to have the easiest time applying it to government and politics. But at what point do the concepts of "questioning" and the notion of "participating" intersect? Becoming a manager was a pivotal point in my life. A place where I had to make the transition from "hating t
Read more

BIRTH OF A BLOG: GUERILLA MARKETING, EFFECTIVE USE OF TECHNOLOGY & GOOD CONTENT WIN THE DAY

Birth of a Blog: Guerilla Marketing, Effective Use of Technology and Good Content Win the Day by pam ashlund A funny thing happened when I started using Technorati. All I wanted was a quick way to see who ( if ANYONE ) was linking to my blog. First, I had to sign up with one of these services and I picked Technorati because it was the first one I came across. Second, I then found out that I was right from the beginning, no one was linking to my site. Third, I decided to try my hand at a bit of self-marketing, which went as follows: Get my brother-in-law to link to my site Set up another dummy blog and link to myself Arm wrestle another friend to link to my site None of that had much of an impact (of course) so I moved on to some actual strategy: Add tags to my blog configuration on Technorati Add tags to my posts (this was painful and manual although I later found a script for it) Test the results - found I showed up in search engines a LITTLE bit more frequently Still no links (tap,
Read more